A Tale of Silence

Poems By Margaret Atwood June 15, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — davidpeacock9 @ 5:21 AM

Margaret Atwood has written many books. She’s written for kids and adults alike but she has also written poems. Here is one of Atwood’s poems.

Siren Song
 
 
  This is the one song everyone
would like to learn: the song
that is irresistible:

the song that forces men
to leap overboard in squadrons
even though they see beached skulls

the song nobody knows
because anyone who had heard it
is dead, and the others can’t remember.
Shall I tell you the secret
and if I do, will you get me
out of this bird suit?
I don’t enjoy it here
squatting on this island
looking picturesque and mythical
with these two feathery maniacs,
I don’t enjoy singing
this trio, fatal and valuable.

I will tell the secret to you,
to you, only to you.
Come closer. This song

is a cry for help: Help me!
Only you, only you can,
you are unique

at last. Alas
it is a boring song
but it works every time.

 

 

History- For those who don’t know. Sirens are from Greek mythology. There were three of them and they lived on an island surrounded by jutting rocks. Sirens are said to be the most beautiful being alive, half woman half bird, they sing a beautiful song that no man can stop listening to. Men became so mesmerized by the song that they would ship wreck and die.

 

 

I Thought that I’d share this poem with you because Margaret Atwood is a Feminist. However, this shows females in somewhat of a bad light. However this poem also shows that Margaret Atwood may view women as being a lot better than men because females able to get males to do whatever they want.

This is just one of many poems Atwood has Written.

 

http://www.poemhunter.com/poem/siren-song/      – This is Where i got Siem Song and there are also many other poems by Margaret Atwood on here.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sirens     – This is my info about Sirens.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Atwood     – This is my information about Atwood being a feminist and the age groups she has written for.

 

 

Like Clockwork June 12, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — margiewaddington @ 9:43 PM

My initially reaction to Clockwork Orange was in a word disturbed, but after watching the whole movie I think it is a film that everyone should watch at least once. It has a clear message that although is thrust in your face is an important one. The topic of violence and sexual abuse is a  relevant topic today and I unfortunately feel it will only get worse from here.

While watching A Clockwork Orange(CO) I noticed a lot of connections between CO and A Handmaid’s Tale(HT). First of all the use of physical violence, basically torture, to control the strong willed characters of Moira and Alex. Alex is not only beat up by his old friends when released but is assaulted by the police when he is arrested and even his treatment through negative conditioning is a form of torture. Moira’s attempt to escape in her form of rebellion is also  met with violence. Her feet are horribly mutilated for her treachery and she is eventually sent to a whorehouse instead. Where she is further degraded but it is preferably for her as she at least has some freedoms like smoking and talking to the other women. In both stories women are degraded and disrespected, and treated as weak creatures that need male protection and support. Alex’s mother is constantly in tears or depicted as brainless and all the other women are shown being raped or in inferior positions. In HT women have no rights at all and are used as incubators for the offspring of the Commanders. Finally there is also a connection through music. Alex is infatuated with Ludwig van and idolizes him. It is a symbol of his true identity and nature throughout the film. In contrast, Offered only connection to music is the songs that she remembers from her past. Even to hum them quietly out loud is a risk as it is against the law to play such music anymore. Instead of being a symbol of her identity or desires the songs she remembers most often are “Amazing Grace” and “Heartbreak Hotel” both songs speak of being lonely, beaten down and isolated from the world. Even to the point of seeking death as a release from such pain (‘ so lonely I could die.’) They represent her present circumstances and her wish for some escape.

Overall I think Alex is the better anti-hero as he is truly evil in nature but as an audience we are still able to find compassion for his situation. Offred although I feel remorse and disgust for her circumstances, is not evil in or ‘anti’ in anyway. Her biggest indiscretion is following her heart and sleeping with Luc, a married man, and later Nick to feel connected to anyone in the hell she lives in.

 

The Clockwork Handmaid June 12, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — davidpeacock9 @ 12:48 AM

The HandmaidsTale and A Clockwork Orange are two completely stories. THT deals with the life of one woman in a time were womans rights are gone and ACO deals with one mans violent behavior and the cruel ways that the government “cures” him. However, there are some similarities between them.

first of all, women dont seem to have as many rights as they should. this could, though, be just Alex’s mother. there arent any other women that impact Alex as much. the entire time she seemed almost druged and out of it. 

the title A Clockwork Orange can almost go with either story, in my opinion.  “A Clockwork Orange” come from the phrase ”As clear as a clockwork orange”. this refers to a mechanically responsive human. It’s fits in A Clockwork Orange because of the mechanical way that Alex responds to violence, sex, and Beethovens 9th. It also fits in The Handmaids Tale because of the mechanical way women are made to do through day to day life. in layman’s terms, Eat, Sleep, Shop, and ceremony. you can almost set your clock to it.

there are some complete differences. actually mostly differences. first and formost are the rapes that happen in A Clockwork Orange. In The Handmaids Tale the people in charge continuosly say over and over again, that thye reason for all of this is to help protect women from things like rape.

However to contradict myself about it being a difference, arent women really getting raped anyway. the ceremony after all is against there free will and the dictionary definition is “any act of sexual intercourse that is forced upon a person”.

the next big difference is the violence. The worls in A Clockwork Orange is full of violence. One of the fist scenes is the three od Alex’s “friends” and Alex beating up an old homeless person, for singing. just acts of mindless senseless violence. But in The Handmaids Tale the punishment for any sort of violence is either banishment or death. few to no crimes are committed in that universe.

these are just a couple of the similarities and differeces between my dystopic literature peice The Handmaids Tale and the dystopic movie A Clockwork Orange. 

 

When Evil Takes Over. June 11, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — somergirl @ 10:58 PM

In A Clockwork Orange, Alex’s favourite things are rape, ultra-violence and Beethoven.  It made me think about how everything evil stems from something good. Rape is a branch off of sex and Beethoven is a brilliant composer of beautiful music. In the movie, after Alex has been “rehabilitated”, his favourite things turn against him and end up causing him the most pain. When he tries to be violent, abuse a female or listen to his favourite composer, he experiences pain at such a level that it ends up causing him to attempt ending his own life.  This made me think about the dystopic genre and how whether in book or movie form, the authors and directors choose to make the topic all the more real by having our favourite or most trusted things/ people turn against us in the future. In The Handmaid’s Tale, Offred loves Luke but ends up growing suspicious of him as men begin gaining the upper hand and the concept of “making love” becomes nothing more than attempting to breed. Women need men in their lives and sex is a natural part of life and yet they were the two man things to be altered in the future as shown in both A Clockwork Orange and The Handmaid’s Tale. 

While both the movie and the book have a very twisted concept of sex and it’s purpose, the women are treated very differently.  In The Handmaid’s Tale, the  Handmaids are basically used as sex slaves but instead of being used for pleasure, they are used so that they may become pregnant. A woman’s worth in the society of Gilead is determined by her “role”. The wives live very sheltered lives with no responsibilities or goals. The Aunts are respected and aren’t bothered but the Handmaid’s are at the bottom of the chain.  

In both my lit. circle novel and the movie portray the future in a very frightening light by taking the things that we generally associate with comfort and love and distorting them to portray fear and control.

What I find most interesting about the movie is that is actually doesn’t show a lot of reasons as to why the people are besides Alex and his gang. It shows the people as being very wary (unwilling to open their doors at night etc.) but it doesn’t show why because their don’t seem to be many psychotic hooligans running around besides Alex and Co. If there were, Alex’s crime would not have been such a big deal in the newspapers etc. because his crimes would have been common. The way I see it, they are attempting to improve their way of life but don’t quite know how to go about it. For example, after Alex gets out of treatment and realizes that the two guys he used to wreak havoc with have become policemen, he can’t believe it, but the reason was that the government was trying to integrate them and give them a role/ purpose in society. It was a nice thought, but clearly was not a good idea.  This was a major difference I saw between my book and the movie. In the movie, they are attempting to keep order in society in a more normal way whereas in The Handmaid’s Tale they try to maintain order by assigning roles and using extremely harsh punishments for those that attempt to rebel.

 

Silence vs. Screams — June 11, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — justadaughter @ 9:55 PM

A Creative Compare and Contrase of Margaret Atwood’s A Handmaid’s Tale and the 1970′s film, A Clockwork Orange.

And the first thing that flashed into my gulliver was that I’d like to have her right down there on the floor with the old in-out, real savage. – Alex DeLarge (A Clockwork Orange)

Sex. Plain and simple, Stanley Kubricks’s adaptation of A Clockwork Orange focuses primarily on rape, and “ultra-violence” all while being put to the lovely classical music background. Alex has an evident psychopathic obessesion with rape, and sexual violence… only towards women. His immediate thoughts when put in a situation with women, those of whom he does not even know, is doing the “old in out” with them, which is what all of us know as sex. I believe that Alex has the temptations to overtake innocent, helpless women as a way of displaying his power, and feeding his cravings to be in charge. This need to be in charge of others is displayed in the way he deals with his other gang members, Pete, Georgie, and Dim, as he must always be in charge of them. In certain circumstances, Alex has even resorted to beating his fellow gang members as a way of teaching them he is in charge, and they must respect them. The sexual assaults on women also display a particular aspect that is associated with a number of dystopic societies such as the Handmaid’s Tale, which is fact that men are superior to women. The men in these socieites must be better, more respected, and hold all power and control over the women.

In The Handmaid’s Tale, the behaviour of  the Commander can be easily compared to that of Alex from A Clockwork Orange. Both men have an obvious need for power over the women in their lives, ensuring that all rights and freedoms be taken away from them. The women are then left defenceless, and with no choice but to comply to the commands of both Alex, and the Commander. Despite their many similarities, there are some differences between the Commander and crazy psycho Alex. The Commander feels a certain amount of pathos for Offred, as he invites her to his room to play scrabble, gives her forbidden facial cream, and allows her to read a “sacred” magazine. This shows the reader that the Commander does indeed have a heart, and still has true emotions despite the society he lives in. Both the novel, and the film are completely twisted, delusional, and just plain weird. Within both dystopic societies, there are certain aspects of the way of life that are can very likely come true within our socities. However, I believe that A Clockwork Orange is more realistic for our society, as extreme violence and rape are alreayd prevelant issues in our world.

 

Handmaid’s Tale And A Clockwork Orange June 11, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — agxo @ 4:50 PM

Wow – Off the top of my head I can not think of any similarities between Handmaid’s Tale and A Clockwork Orange. Offred is this laid back, sentimental woman whereas Alex is this horribly cruel person. The Commander and Alex can somewhat be compared.

Alex is a young man who commits crime and loves his sex. He doesn’t care basically about anybody except for himself. This all changes after he is put in jail and offers to do a new technological project which was supposed to stop criminals from doing crime. Alex was forced to watch extremely violent films along with his favourite music – Beethoven. Alex finishes the program and when he is faced with a situation at all, even if it involves self defense, Alex finds it impossible to hurt anybody physically. Today being day two of watching the film, I developed pathos towards Alex. When the Police officers started dunking his head under water after watching him be beat by a group of old men, I felt unbelievably horrible that Alex could not defend himself. I could not help but feel sorry for the same man who brutally beat and raped people at the beginning of the film.

The Commander is seen as this evil person just like Alex is. Technically, he rapes Offred to try to get her pregnant. Pathos is also developed for the Commander when he starts to get Offred to sneak off to his room to play Scrabble. The Commander even feels alone in a society that he controls. I think this is how Alex feels in A Clockwork Orange as well. He holds so much power, and he knows it yet he still feels so alone.

A Clockwork Orange seems so unbelievably realistic in my eyes but maybe if I read the book it would be different. I find that the rape and abuse that goes on in this film is mocking rape and violence in real life. Everything is just too – happy – for a dystopic piece (for me anyways!).

 

Juxtaposition June 10, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — margiewaddington @ 11:05 PM

Offred is not only weighed against her friend Moria as a rebellious woman, but her shopping partner Offglen is also part of the resistance movement. ( I appologise in advance for Atwoods twisted sence of humour in making all the handmaids names start with ‘Off’) Offglen offers Offred a chance to escape early on as they become more familiar with each other. Offred is part of an undergroud group that is trying to overthrow “The Eye’s” (even more eye imagery!) They collect information about the commanders and anything that they can. They have created a code word ‘Mayday’ (which as most ofyou know is a modern times military distress call) that would signal a handmaid in trouble and they would be evacuated from Gilead but it is only done in extreme circumstances. The rebels are smart and allow everyone to know only one other person in the group so that if anyone is caught only 1 other person is at risk. Offglen is outgoing and hardened by her situation. At one point her fellow rebel is thrown into a mass of Handmaids to be beaten after being accused of a violent rape which he didn’t commit. Instead of shinking away as she was forced to watch her friend be beaten to death she is the first to jump in and mercifully knocks him out cold as quickly as possible to save him the pain. In contrast, Offred cringed from the attack and even accusses Offglen of being icious in her assault of the man. As I have mentioned previously Offred is to docile to take any action and even when given the chance to help in relative safety refuses to help the very people that eventually save her life. Some people who have read the book may argue that Offglen is just as weak as she does commit suicide at the end of the novel. But in my opinion she only does this because she hears the ‘Eyes’ coming and does not want to forfeit information during the interogation. Even in her death she is being corageous and sacrificing herself for the resistance.

I pose a question though, if Margaret Atwood is a strong feminist why would she kill off all of the strong, leaders that are female in her novel and rescue the women who is essentially a doormat?

 

Offreds Love Life June 10, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — davidpeacock9 @ 5:49 AM

i belive that margaret atwood at first tried to make luke and the commander have somewhat the same role as eachother to Offred. before Offred marries luke they have to sneak around because luke is already married. the same goes for the commander. Offred and the Commander have to sneak aroung behind Serena Joy’s back, not to “fool around”  necessarily, but so that Offred can read and have hand lotion and do other things that are illegal for women to be doing. i realize that offred feels completly different about them. she loves luke and didnt much like the commander, but that wa why nick was there. nick was owned by the commander and through him helping the commander out with getting offred to the study, offred fell in love with him. after she fell in love with nick, nich became the new luke. however, before all of this, when luke and offred were fooling around behind luke’s wife’s back, offred would go to a hotel room and wait for luke. now, nick waits for offred in his room and offred is the one sneaking around behind the commanders back. Offred switches to lukes role when she falls in love with nick. could this be foreshadowing something?

 

Genre Comparisons & Contrasts along with juxtaposition of characters! June 9, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — somergirl @ 11:02 PM

Clockwork Orange & The Handmaid’s Tale:

Both are futuristic and portray a dystopia. Women are definitely of a lower ranking than men in each and in both the women seem helpless and unable to fight back. The prospect is very frightening. I haven’t seen enough of The Clockwork Orange yet to determine how society changed to become what it has but in The Handmaid’s Tale it was clearly explained how women could quickly have their rights (and lives) swept out from under them. So far I am thoroughly creeped out by the movie but I can’t help but want to watch more in order to understand what in the world is going on and to discover the message behind it. What we were discussing at the end of class today reminded of that YouTube clip we watched, the “Lost Generation” that talked about how easily work could become more important than family etc. The movie showed just that. The main character’s mom works in a factory all day and then takes sleeping pills so she is very uninvolved in her son’s life and his goings-ons so she is thoroughly unaware of all the sick and twisted past-times he takes part in. The movie also brought my novel to mind in their treatment of the elderly. In The Handmaid’s Tale the elderly are shipped off to the colonies to work around dangerous material until they die and the opening scene of the movie showed just what the future generation felt towards old people (kicking/ beating up the old man). I find it very interesting that all of these dystopic novels/ movies portray females and the elderly as the ones being largely abused instead of exploring a future in which women rule or a society in which the oldest are the most respected. Why do you guys think this is?

 

Juxtaposition of Character:

As Ashley said, I think Atwood does a great job juxtaposing Serena Joy and Offred because both of their sufferings come from different perspectives stemming from the same problem (The Commander). I also think that Luke and Nick are compared in Offred’s thoughts as she remembers back to her life with Luke and finds herself desiring Nick because she knows she can’t have him.  She ends up using Nick to rebel against the life she hates in an attempt to cope with something to look forward to at the end of the day. It’s interesting that Atwood chose to have Luke as a married man and had Offred sneaking away to sleep with him before he got a divorce and then her life changed and it is now her duty to allow a married man to have sex with her body. Talk about ironic!

 

Go on and grow some… June 9, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — justadaughter @ 10:53 PM

“Go on and grow some”… testicles, or how most of us know it as the uncensored version… balls. One character throughout the novel in particular is whom I intend to direct this statement at. For those of you who have read it, I’m sure you already know. For those of you who haven’t, you’ll soon find out.

For the juxtaposition of characters, I decided that I would compare and contrast Offred, the main character, and Moira, Offred’s best friend and college roomate from their life before the Gilead Government took over. However, despite that they were best friends from before, Moira is brought into the house and becomes another handmaid, along with Offred. As readers we are presented with two very different characters, yet they had so many important experiences together, the most important being their lives as handmaids.

Offred, the narrarator of the novel is a generally passive woman. She is kind hearted, yet does not give into the new life she is forced to lead. Offred, who does not reveal her name in the “time before”, believes that there will be a way out eventually, and she will no longer have to live for nothing other than bearing the Commander’s child. As mentioned earlier, Offred is passive – which is clearly demonstrated thoughout the novel as she tends to shy away from situations that could have severe consequences. She has little courage, and will go along with what is expected of the handmaid’s in order to survive. She will do anything to stay away from the wall, as she cannot imagine hanging there dead in front of all to be just another “example.” The lack of courage has transformed Offred into a woman like everyone else, conformed to their new societal norms, stipped from her freedom, her knowledge, her voice.

Moira on the other hand, now she has some serious balls. This girl is gutsy, she’s bold, and she’s on the edge, all in despite of her situation and circumstances. Yes, she too was a handmaid, living in the same corridors as Offred, under the same rules and watch of the aunts, but she was unique. The difference between Moira and Offred was she was anything but niave, and Moira knew that there was no “maybe” of getting out of that place alive. Being the rebellious woman she was, Moira made her first attempt to escape by faking sick, with the hopes that she would be taken to the hospital, where there she would escape from the Guardians. Although her first attempt failed and she had her feet brutally mutulated as a consequence, Moira did anything but give up. The second time, she got it right. A clever (as Kailee would say) ploy to louer one of the Aunts into the bathroom led to Moira dismantling the toilet and threatening to kill her. She managed to get the aunt to the basement, and tie her up behind a furnance, stealing her clothing and acting as if she were Aunt Elizabeth. This allowed Moira to walk right past the guards, and into the path of her escape. Some may call it crazy, I call it courageous.

Whether or not you take the ending of the novel into consideration, where Offred becomes a little riskier with Nick, and Moira gets caught nine months later, that’s up to you. However, for the most part, this is how I saw it, and it will remain the view that I have of the two characters. Their dynamic personalities and differences are what brought them together in the first place, and those qualities are what makes readers fall in love with both characters in their own ways. If you were in Offred’s position, would you too conform to their way of life, making sure not to break any rules in order to survive? Or knowing your chances of child bearing and survival in the long run, would you make an attempt to escape while you could?

— Whether you agree or not, I think Moira’s one crazy woman, and Offred, point blank just needs to grow some. :)

 

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.